If you'd like to see this header supported by Mozilla, vote for bug #37028
From: "J. Moreno"
Newsgroups: news.software.readers Subject: Re: Mail-Copies-To draft Date: Wed, 17 Nov 1999 12:22:13 -0500 Message-ID: <firstname.lastname@example.org> The proposal below mainly just documents current practice (supported by at /least/ 13 newsreaders: AdBuster, Gnus, Hogwasher, Internews, MacSOUP, Messenger Pro, MT-NewsWatcher, NewsHound, NewsReader.Com, NewsWatcher, rnr, Slrn, YA-NewsWatcher -- Deja.com allows setting the header but doesn't otherwise support it, deja.com also reports more than 600,000 articles with it mentioned). Modified 11/16/99: "sender" has been dropped due to lack of use and possible confusion. No longer refers to Spencers draft but instead [MESSFOR} and a Reference section added. From-content has been replaced with mailbox, to indicate that the address is a full internet address, including a FQDN, and that it is limited to a SINGLE address (both USEFOR and MESSFOR are going to allow multiple addresses in From and Reply-To but it is pretty much unanimously agreed that such would be wrong for the MCT header). Some slight grammar changes have been made for clarity (thanks to Alan Mackenzie). Modifed 11/17/99: changed "affect" to "effect". Comments? ************************************************************************ Mail-Copies-To This header specifies a single internet e-mail address, or one of several keywords. The keywords are not case sensitive. This header only effects the initial, default settings of the message by the Followup/Reply Agent and the user MUST be able to change those settings. If the keywords "nobody" or "never" are used, the agent MUST NOT set the message for an e-mail copy to be sent, and MUST provide a warning if the user tries to set it so that it will be. If either the keyword "poster" or "always" is used, the agent SHOULD set the message to have an e-mail copy sent to the reply address, and it MUST provide a warning before allowing the user to change this. If the content of the header is a syntactically valid e-mail address which does not end in ".invalid", the agent MAY set the message to having an e-mail copy, and if it does so it MUST initially use the specified address, and a warning SHOULD be issued before allowing the user to change it. The presence or absence of this header MUST NOT have any effect when a reply is sent by e-mail instead of posted. This header MUST effect only e-mail copies of followups and the agent SHOULD allow the user to send a copy or not regardless of this header. When a copy is e-mailed, the agent SHOULD indicate in the message that it was both mailed and posted. If the header is not present the agent SHOULD NOT set the message to be both posted and mailed. The user may do so, but a warning is not necessary before allowing this. =============== Notes This describes what several UseNet news readers are doing with the Mail-Copies-To header. Following the format in [MESSFOR], the syntax is specified as: copy-addr = name-addr / addr-spec Mail-Copies-To-content = copy-addr / "nobody" / "never" / "poster" / "always" NOTE: This differs from From-content used by MESSFOR by only allowing a single address and by exluding "obs-mailbox". As defined by MESSFOR, addr-spec requires a FQDN. The keywords "never" and "always" are included for legacy reasons, and because they may be directly entered by the user, but the keywords "nobody" and "poster" are preferred and SHOULD be used instead. There are two methods for "indicating in the message that it was both mailed and posted". One is to use a header field (at the time of this writing Posted-And-Mailed is proposed with a content of either yes or no). The other method is to insert a note as the first line(s) of the message, and if this method is used the line(s) MUST be inserted into both the news and mail messages. Both usages are equally valid, and it appears the compromise may be to do both. Rationale The reasons for allowing an address are to allow the poster to specify a special address as a destination for copies of posted replies and to allow people posting with an invalid address to specify a valid address to which to send a Cc. Only one address is allowed, so as to limit the potential for abuse. Note on Compatibility The agent MUST NOT generate and post anything but an e-mail address or one of the specified keywords (this does not imply any additional validation of headers entered directly by the user). References: [MESSFOR] Network Working Group Internet-Draft Internet Message Format Standard -- John Moreno